Meanwhile, higher education funding has dropped by 16 percent, tuition to community colleges has doubled, and the cost of attending public four-year universities has gone up by 50 percent.
Cooper was elected in 2016, and his administration has stressed the importance of investing in education. “It’s not like the old days, when my parents’ generation could drop out of high school and work in the mill—it’s a very aggressive world [now],” says Tony Copeland, North Carolina’s secretary of commerce. “The public sector has to move rapidly to address the changing nature of education and workforce needs. Funding is critical.” But the administration can do only so much, since legislators control appropriations. (Republican leaders did not respond to requests for comment for this story.)
Businesses still appreciate cheap labor—and low taxes—but education is at a premium. That’s obviously true for tech firms like Amazon, which has added North Carolina’s Triangle region to its short list for a new headquarters. But even old-economy manufacturing firms need a trained workforce to run their increasingly advanced machinery.
“That’s one of the bedrocks of firm attraction,” along with strong infrastructure, says Megan Randall, an Urban Institute researcher who focuses on economic development and finance. “Everyone needs and wants a skilled workforce, and those come through investments at each step of the way, early childhood through higher education.”
Indeed, studies repeatedly show that fully funding education as early as pre-k pays off handsomely down the line. Unfortunately, however, few politicians—in North Carolina or nationally—take that long view.
“In the U.S., we do a very bad job of training people in specific industries. It’s short term thinking,” says Ryan McDevitt, an economics professor at Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business. “We need to commit to education over the next ten or 20 years, so that when the next generation of manufacturing comes online, we’re ready.”
Surprisingly, Alabama, which frequently lies near the bottom on U.S. quality of life indicators, seems to have learned that lesson well. Huntsville is a particularly strong example. The city is home to a large science and tech research park whose establishment in 1961 spurred the local schools to focus on STEM subjects. “We’ve always had to make sure we’re producing an educated workforce for that field,” says Shane Davis, Huntsville’s head of urban and economic development.
Today, the k-12 system familiarizes even students who won’t be going to college with 3-D printers and computer-based machines so that they’re ready to work in sophisticated manufacturing settings. And the region’s higher education institutions, particularly its two community colleges, work directly with local industry, creating classes that meet firms’ specific needs and pivoting as technology advances.
“Education is huge here,” says Davis. Manufacturers, as well as government agencies like NASA and the Department of Defense, have recognized that fact, and built on it over the last quarter-century. But it started with government investment.
North Carolina’s rural counties, which haven’t fully recovered from the recession, could use that kind of jump-start. In the past, sector strategies—partnerships between industry and educators to tailor workers’ skills to employers’ needs—have succeeded in boosting fields like biotech and aerospace outside of the state’s urban cores.
That could work again, says Allan Freyer, director of the Workers’ Rights Project at the NC Justice Center. But legislators are ideologically opposed to industry-specific investments. “The legislature gives lip service to training the workforce, but it doesn’t put money where its mouth is,” he says.
But education funding isn’t just about training a current and future workforce. It’s also a proxy for a community’s priorities, says Brent Lane, an economic strategist at UNC’s Kenan Institute of Private Enterprise.
“Anyone who’s considering opening a business in a community will certainly be concerned about the quality of public education—not just because of workers, but because it’s a reflection of the quality of life that they and their employees would experience,” he explains. “How good of a place is this to live? Is it clean, is it safe, do they share our priorities on diversity and tolerance?”
Unfortunately, in North Carolina, investments in some of those broader indicators are down, too. Funding for corrections and public safety has been cut, and environmental regulation has been deeply reduced.
A well-funded educational system is the key to strong, long-term growth. But conservatives—in North Carolina and around the country—are doing everything in their power to undermine that system. In fact, the U.S. as a whole seems poised to go down the same road North Carolina is traveling. The Trump administration is pulling back from federal investments; among many other areas, it’s cutting technical training programs and trying to overhaul traditional public education. The grim irony is that, if President Trump were serious about bringing more manufacturing jobs to the country, he would be launching fewer trade wars and encouraging his Republican allies to invest more at home.